In brief
The New History of the Five Dynasties writes that once enthroned he proved unequal to the task. The discussion on the biographies of Xiao Yi and others in the Shiguo Chunqiu cites commentators who said that he and Liu Sheng were both dissolute and cruel, and concludes that setting up the elder is the correct principle.
Road to the throne
His original name was Hongdu, and he was enfeoffed as Prince of Qin. According to the Zizhi Tongjian and the Shiguo Chunqiu, in 934, after being put in charge of the Six Armies, he became intimate with a crowd of petty men, and when the chief minister Yang Dongqian remonstrated, his father brushed it aside, saying he was only teaching the boy military matters. Lying ill, Liu Yan wished to set up Hongchang: according to the New History of the Five Dynasties and the biography of Hongchang, Prince of Yue, in the Shiguo Chunqiu, he said that Hongdu and Hongxi were unequal to the task and that only Hongchang resembled him, while according to the Zizhi Tongjian he had seen the arrogance of the two. Xiao Yi remonstrated that the elder should be set up, and when Liu Yan died in 942, Hongdu took the throne and changed his name to Bin.
Reign and death
According to the New History of the Five Dynasties and the Shiguo Chunqiu, while Liu Yan's coffin still lay in state, he had actors play music as he drank, and in mourning dress he went in and out of commoners' houses at night with prostitutes. According to the Zizhi Tongjian and the Shiguo Chunqiu, those around him were put to death if they crossed his wishes, so none of them remonstrated; only Hongchang, Prince of Yue, and one other man remonstrated repeatedly, and were not heeded. According to the Zizhi Tongjian and the Shiguo Chunqiu, Zhang Yuxian rebelled in 942; the younger brothers sent to suppress him were surrounded and barely escaped, and Zhang Yuxian took Xunzhou. Hongxi, Prince of Jin, offered him female entertainers to lure him into debauchery, and Liu Bin, suspecting that his younger brothers were plotting against him, had eunuchs guard the palace gates and strip and search everyone who entered. Because Liu Bin was fond of unarmed combat, according to the Zizhi Tongjian and the Shiguo Chunqiu, Hongxi ordered Chen Daoxiang to train strongmen in it. The New History of the Five Dynasties says that three of the brothers, Hongxi, Honggao and Hongchang, gave the order in secret. In 943, as he feasted with the princes at the Changchun Palace, watched bouts of unarmed combat and became very drunk, he was killed by Chen Daoxiang, Liu Sichao and others. The Zizhi Tongjian and the Shiguo Chunqiu say they took him under both arms and killed him, while the New History of the Five Dynasties says they followed him to the door of his bedchamber and killed him. The next morning, in the Zizhi Tongjian and in the annals of Liu Sheng in the Shiguo Chunqiu, Hongchang led his younger brothers to the hall of the bedchamber and received Hongxi and set him on the throne as Liu Sheng. The biography of Hongchang, Prince of Yue, writes that Hongchang led troops and received Hongxi in the hall of the bedchamber.
Translated from the Japanese text of this site, which is written from the official histories. Years are the Western calendar years of the dates, as in English reference works. Months are omitted because the histories use the Chinese lunar calendar.