In brief
In his assessment, Chen Shou says that Sun Xiu gave office to Puyang Xing and Zhang Bu without being able to promote men of talent and did not let the deposed Sun Liang die a proper death, while the Bianwang Lun of Lu Ji cited in Pei Songzhi's commentary calls him a good ruler who preserved what had been established.
Road to the throne
In 252 he was made Prince of Langya, and when Sun Liang succeeded to the throne he was moved to Danyang Commandery and then to Kuaiji. In 258, after Sun Liang plotted to have Sun Chen put to death and was reduced to Prince of Kuaiji, Sun Chen, on the advice of Shi Zheng, decided to set up Sun Xiu. Sun Xiu was suspicious at first, but he set out after the envoys explained matters to him, and he took the throne after declining three times.
Reign and death
The five marquises of Sun Chen's family all commanded the palace troops, and Sun Xiu, fearing trouble from them, repeatedly bestowed rewards. When Sun Chen spoke resentfully in Zhang Bu's presence, saying that the emperor would not have been enthroned but for him, Sun Xiu held it against him, and later, hearing of a plot by Sun Chen, he made secret plans with Zhang Bu and early in 259, at the La sacrifice, had Sun Chen seized and put to death. In 260 a rumor spread that Sun Liang would return as Son of Heaven, and after his palace staff accused him of curses he was demoted to Marquis of Houguan and killed himself on the way to his fief; the Wulu cited in Pei Songzhi's commentary records an account that Sun Xiu had him poisoned. From 262 he entrusted the government to the chancellor Puyang Xing and to Zhang Bu, to whom he was bound by old favors. Sun Xiu loved the classics and wanted to read all the works of the hundred schools, and he put his books down only on the days in spring and summer when he went out to shoot pheasants. In the same year he wanted to hold discussions with the Libationer of the Erudites Wei Yao and others, but he was blocked by Zhang Bu, who feared that his own faults would be pointed out, and although displeased he gave up out of concern over Zhang Bu's suspicion. According to the Wulu cited in Pei Songzhi's commentary, he created characters not used in the world to give names and courtesy names to his four sons, and Pei Songzhi criticized these as characters and sounds without precedent. He died in 264 and was given the posthumous name Emperor Jing; the main text of his biography in the Records of the Three Kingdoms does not state the cause of his death, but an edict of Cao Wei reports that Sun Xiu died of illness, and the Jiangbiao Zhuan cited in Pei Songzhi's commentary records that Sun Xiu, unable to speak because of his illness, took Puyang Xing by the arm and entrusted his son to him. After his death, amid a wish for an older ruler, Puyang Xing and Zhang Bu, on the recommendation of Wan Yu and with the consent of Empress Dowager Zhu, set aside Sun Xiu's legitimate son and brought in and enthroned Sun Hao. Sun Hao later drove Empress Dowager Zhu, whom he had demoted to Empress Jing, to her death, and killed the two eldest of Sun Xiu's sons.
Translated from the Japanese text of this site, which is written from the official histories. Years are the Western calendar years of the dates, as in English reference works. Months are omitted because the histories use the Chinese lunar calendar.