In brief
The discussion in the Draft History of Qing says that he carried on the lenient government of the Kangxi Emperor with strictness and clarity, and that although he was suspected of coldness toward his brothers, this did not come only from a lack of feeling on his part. The same discussion praises his words when he rebuffed a close official who said the revenue of the prefectures and counties should be cut, asking how a man who had never served in a prefecture or county could know how hard it was.
Road to the throne
He was the fourth son of the Kangxi Emperor, and was made Prince Yong in 1709. According to the annals in the Draft History of Qing, in 1722 he was summoned by the dying Kangxi Emperor, an edict was proclaimed that he should succeed to the throne, and he took the throne after the emperor's death. The annals of the Kangxi Emperor record only his death, and the Draft History of Qing contains neither the clause of a testamentary edict naming the successor nor any story that a succession to the fourteenth son was rewritten. The biographies in the Draft History of Qing also record that the princes and Longkodo were summoned to the deathbed, but the words announcing that the fourth son would succeed are not in the Draft History of Qing; they are in the Veritable Records. He himself later said that Longkodo was the only minister who received the late emperor's instructions when he died. Among the charges against Longkodo is one that he falsely claimed to have carried a dagger at that time although he was not at the emperor's side.
Reign and death
In 1723 he announced that he had sealed the name of his successor and placed it behind the plaque, and said that under the late emperor the matter had been settled with a single word in haste. In 1725, when Nian Gengyao wrote the phrase zhaoqian xiti as xiti zhaoqian in a memorial, he rebuked him harshly, saying that Nian simply did not grant that the emperor was diligent day and night. To his younger brother Yinsi he issued an edict that rebuked him while saying he valued his talent, and in 1726 he removed him from the imperial clan, saying Yinsi had himself cut his ties with Heaven, the ancestors and the emperor. In 1726 he ordered Nian Gengyao to die and then made Yinsi change his name to Akina, and in 1727 he had Longkodo imprisoned for life. The discussion after the biographies of the Kangxi Emperor's sons says that he later regretted the prosecutions of Yinsi and others. In 1727 he struck his son Hongshi from the imperial clan register as dissolute and lacking restraint. He had the confession Zeng Jing made in 1729 compiled into the Dayi Juemi Lu and expounded in Jiangning and other places, and pardoned Zeng Jing, but Zeng was executed after the Qianlong Emperor took the throne. In 1730, when his younger brother Yinxiang was dying, he went to visit him himself but arrived too late; he suspended court for 3 days and said Yinxiang had served him for 8 years as if it were a single day. When the empress died the next year, he tried to attend her encoffining although he had only just recovered from illness, but was held back; he said she had been filial and respectful without change for more than 40 years. In 1735 he fell ill at the Yuanming Yuan, became critically ill the next day and passed the throne to his fourth son Hongli, and died the day after. The Draft History of Qing does not give his cause of death, and contains nothing that suggests elixirs or poison. The Qing Veritable Records contain an entry in which the Qianlong Emperor, after taking the throne, sent home Zhang Taixu and others, whom the late emperor had placed in the Western Park to try out their furnace-alchemy techniques, saying their medicines had not been used. Partly on the strength of this entry, some research infers poisoning by elixirs, and this site records his cause of death as disputed.
Translated from the Japanese text of this site, which is written from the official histories. Years are the Western calendar years of the dates, as in English reference works. Months are omitted because the histories use the Chinese lunar calendar.